Corbyn & Brexit

At this point this brief post might not serve any good purpose, however….

Key to Corbyn’s appeal is that he is an honest, decent, different kind of politician.  A man of integrity.  Yes, he may not be polished or media friendly but he means what he says.  He’s someone you can believe in.

corbyn integrity

However, there has also been the persistent rumour that he wasn’t really a Remainer at all but a secret Leaver who fronted a lackluster Labour Remain campaign.  This is particularly important as many of his supporters were young, ardent Remainers who have the most to lose from Brexit.

This rumour has been dismissed by these same supporters as agitation by bitter “Blairite” MPs. Lets consider some of the evidence:

We now have the Labour Manifesto, and this comment from Ian Dunt on it’s contents:

corbyn

Is this fair? Has Corbyn always been in the 3rd anti-single market camp?

jceu

This was a comment from Sept 2016 made by a Corbyn aid.  It’s a confusing message (not least because it fundamentally misunderstands the single market) however it clearly mentions Corbyn’s issues with State aid & nationalisation with regards to the EU & the Single Market.  He was “campaigning against” these “aspects” of the EU in the middle of a campaign to stay in the EU.

How can you be for the EU if you have always wanted to engage in significant nationalisation & state aid programs?  If Corbyn believes that the new Manifesto would be incompatible with these aims, then how could he be a remainer?

 

We need to cast our minds back to September 2015, when Corbyn had his first surprising leadership win.  His historical anti EU stance was well known & the PLP knew the referendum was coming so they all met him to question him on his plans and thoughts. He’d been elected by a significant number of new Labour supporters however these supporters were overwhelmingly pro-remain & he had no support in the PLP.

If it became clear that he was still as anti EU as he had been his entire political career, what impact would this have had on his new support base?

However, following the meeting almost all of the PLP were convinced (or let themselves be convinced) that he really had adjusted his views on the EU (they quickly changed their minds after the result but that’s another story).  One however, Chuka Umunna, wasn’t.  He resigned the bench, saying this:

It is my view that we should support the UK remaining a member of the EU, notwithstanding the outcome of any renegotiation by the prime minister, and I cannot envisage any circumstances where I would be campaigning alongside those who would argue for us to leave; Jeremy has made it clear to me that he does not wholeheartedly share this view

So, did Jeremy Corbyn really change his mind on the EU (whilst maintaining all of his other 40 year old beliefs, including those on state aid & nationalisation but on this one issue lining up with his new supporters), lose the referendum with sadness, ask for immediate Article 50 invocation “by mistake” and then think “well, there’s no chance of staying in the SM so we may as well put in place all the nationalisation & state aid programs the EU was stopping us doing”?

a50

Or was Chuka Umunna right?

Because if he was right, then Corbyn was never really a Remainer.

And if he wasn’t, then he misled all those thousands of new supporters at the worst possible time.

And if that’s true, then the whole persona of a “decent man of integrity, not like all the other politicians” comes crashing down.

 

 

 

 

 

Advertisements

One comment

  1. Makes sense. Credit to Chuka for spotting this deception earlier than most.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Nog's Musings

Brexit and other Mythical Creatures

Koenfucius

An ongoing quest for wisdom

expatpartnersurvival.wordpress.com/

The one-stop site for "trailing spouses."

Interface Financial Planning

Live your life to the full and ensure that your money adds meaning to your life

Shane O'Mara

brains, behaviour, organisations

Flip Chart Fairy Tales

Business Bullshit, Corporate Crap and other stuff from the World of Work

Joining The Dots

by Anthony Allinson

%d bloggers like this: